Bureau of Investigation - Insurance Fraud Unit

  • Purpose
  • Contact Us / Report Insurance Fraud
  • Disaster Fraud
  • What Can You Do?
  • Annual Report
  • News Flash / Arrests
  • Newsletter
  • Insurance Fraud Statistics
  • Red Flags of Insurance Fraud
  • Other Links


  • Purpose

    The Insurance Fraud Unit is responsible for investigating referrals of suspected fraudulent insurance acts; assisting federal and local law enforcement in the investigation of fraudulent insurance acts; cooperating with local prosecutors and the attorney general's office in the prosecution of fraudulent insurance acts; and promoting awareness of insurance fraud throughout the state.




    Contact Us / Report Insurance Fraud

    If you have any knowledge of a fraudulent scheme, report the activity to the Louisiana State Police by:

    E-mail:

    Phone: (225) 925-3818

    Fax: (225) 925-3819

    Mail:
    Louisiana State Police
    Bureau of Investigation
    Insurance Fraud Unit
    7919 Independence Blvd.
    Baton Rouge, LA 70806






    Disaster Fraud

    State Licensing Board for Contractors

    NICB Indicators of Catastrophe Fraud

    Warning Signs of Contractor Fraud

    Before You Hire a Contractor

    Repairing Your Home After a Disaster

    Tips to Avoid Disaster Fraud




    What Can You Do?

    • Be aware of staged accidents, such as intentional sideswiping or cars that cut in front of other vehicles, forcing collisions due to quick stops.

    • Be aware of individuals that try to get you to leave the scene of an accident without calling police or obtaining a police report.

    • Be aware that some individuals report damage as vandalism in an attempt to cover deliberate or previous damage to one's own property.

    • Be aware of individuals making a false stolen vehicle claim to cover previous damage to a vehicle or to dispose of the vehicle.

    • Be aware of individuals that inflate genuine claims to cover a policy deductible.

    • Be aware of attempts to convince you that "everybody is getting rich" so you may as well try to get additional money also.

    • Be aware of the possibility that someone may set a small fire in their home to obtain a new paint or remodeling job.

    • Be aware of individuals that fake an on-the-job injury to stay off work after healing to collect Workers' Compensation benefits.



    Annual Report

    2007 Annual Report
    2006 Annual Report
    2006 Annual Report Supplement

    2005 Annual Report

    Hurricane Katrina Year in Review

    To view or print the reports you will need Adobe Acrobat Reader installed on your computer.  To download the free software click on the button below:
    acrobat.gif




    News Flash

    August 23, 2007

    On Thursday August 23, 2007, a St. Tammany Parish resident was arrested on an arrest warrant obtained by the Louisiana State Police Insurance Fraud and Auto Theft Unit. The arrest evolved from a complaint by a private insurance company.

    Troopers believe George Amann III filed a fraudulent Business Interruption commercial insurance claim by falsely stating he was unable to conduct business due to the damages and events which followed Hurricane Katrina. Based on his claim, Amann’s insurer advanced him $100,000 to cover the interruption of his business. However, an investigation revealed his ability to conduct business had not been interrupted by the storm. He conducted business with approximately fifty-five separate entities and received approximately $288,000 from business transactions during the period he claimed he was unable to conduct any business.

    An arrest warrant charging Amann with one (1) count of Insurance Fraud and one (1) count of Felony Theft was obtained in Jefferson Parish as Jefferson Parish was the location of his business. Amann turned himself over to Troopers from the Louisiana State Police Insurance Fraud and Auto Unit and was subsequently booked into the Jefferson Parish Jail.

    July 26, 2007

    On July 26, 2007, the Louisiana State Police Insurance Fraud / Auto Theft Unit Alexandria Field Office, working in conjunction with the Allen Parish Sheriff’s Department, concluded a five month investigation into allegations of Auto Theft being conducted by the proprietor of a Towing and Storage Company in the Oakdale area of Allen Parish. David Allison, 39, 1026 Hudson Street, Oakdale, Louisiana, was arrested and charged with 3 counts of Possession of Stolen Property.

    The joint investigation began in March of 2007 after a concerned citizen called in a complaint of a suspicious vehicle allegedly left in the community by David Allison. A preliminary investigation made by the Allen Parish Sheriff’s Department and the Oakdale Police Department indicated that the vehicle had been reported stolen and never recovered. The Allen Parish Sheriff’s Department contacted the State Police Insurance Fraud / Auto Theft Division for support. On March 28, 2007, investigators from State Police, the Allen Parish Sheriff’s Department, and the Oakdale Police Department searched three properties in Allen Parish either owned by or leased to Allison. During these searches, investigators recovered a total of eight stolen vehicles. All of the recovered vehicles had been reported stolen from Allen Parish, Rapides Parish, Calcasieu Parish, or from the State of Arizona. State Police alleged that Allison was hiding the vehicles in multiple locations to avoid detection by law enforcement.

    At the end of the investigation, a District Court Judge in Oberlin signed arrest warrants for Allison, charging him with three counts of Possession of Stolen Property, which was valued in excess of $23,230.00. Allison was arrested by Allen Parish Deputies and State Police Investigators at his home in Oakdale, Louisiana. Allison was booked into the Allen Parish Jail. Allison, if convicted, faces a term of imprisonment, with or without hard labor, not to exceed ten years on each count.

    State Police wishes to remind everyone that citizen involvement and awareness is key to law enforcement’s goal of community safety and protection of property. The degree of success achieved by law enforcement in this investigation would not have been possible without community involvement and the selfless cooperation displayed by the Allen Parish Sheriff’s Department, the Oakdale Police Department, and the Louisiana State Police Bureau of Investigation. State Police recommends that anyone having information concerning the identity of persons selling or storing stolen vehicles, or the location of stolen vehicles, should not hesitate to contact State Police or their local law enforcement agencies.

    June 8, 2007

    The Louisiana State Police Insurance Fraud and Auto Theft Unit announced today the arrest of seven individuals on insurance fraud and theft warrants in the past two weeks. The arrests continue as the Insurance Fraud and Auto Theft Unit focuses their efforts on catching persons who attempt to gain financially from insurance fraud and disaster fraud related activities.

    John Henry Strong, of Mulberry Street, Eudora, Arkansas, was arrested on May 25, 2007, after filing a fraudulent auto theft report. Strong told the West Carroll Parish Sheriff’s Office that his 2004 Dodge Ram was stolen while he was fishing near Jones, Louisiana. Strong filed an insurance claim and his insurer issued a check in the amount of $20,555.00 payable to Strong and the vehicle’s lien holder. However, Strong’s daughter was found to be in possession of the vehicle, with his permission, after she was stopped for speeding in Kansas. Strong was arrested and charged in West Carroll Parish with Insurance Fraud and Felony Theft.

    Patrick Richard, of 7th Avenue, Lake Charles, Louisiana, was arrested on May 29, 2007. Richard filed a claim with his insurer for Additional Living Expenses (ALE) after Hurricane Rita. Richard submitted for reimbursement a hand written receipt and letter purportedly from his mother indicating she had charged him $300 a day to stay at her home. The total amount of the fictitious receipt was $10,500.00. Richard’s mother denied ever charging her son for his stay and Richard admitted to Troopers he generated the fraudulent documents in an attempt to recoup his losses from the Hurricane. Richard was arrested and charged in Calcasieu Parish with Insurance Fraud.

    Dionne Marie Williams, a.k.a. Dion Smith, of Billineys Park Drive, Katy, Texas, was arrested on May 31, 2007. Williams is believed to have filed false medical bills with her insurer. Williams told her insurer that her three minor children had to be treated at a medical facility in Hammond, Louisiana, after an automobile crash. However, the medical facility verified the children had never been treated there. Williams was arrested near Houston after the warrant for her arrest was entered into the National Crime Information Computer (NCIC). She was extradited back to Louisiana where she will be charged with Automobile Insurance Policy Fraud in East Baton Rouge Parish.

    Christopher Bonier, of Carrolls Camp, Chestnut, Louisiana, and Liza Telsee, of Lebrum Street, Campti, Louisiana, were arrested on June 5, 2007, after they intentionally crashed the tractor portion of a tractor-trailer for the sole purpose of filing fraudulent property damage and bodily injury insurance claims. The State Police investigation revealed Telsee and Bonier staged the crash by disconnecting a flatbed trailer from the tractor, then steering the tractor off the road into a nearby tree. The two claimed the trailer was defective and separated from the tractor while the vehicle was traveling at 55 miles per hour – but the evidence at the scene clearly did not match their statements. Bonier and Telsee were arrested and charged with Insurance Fraud in Red River Parish.

    Michael Donald Graves, of East Texas Avenue, Bossier City, Louisiana, was arrested on June 6, 2007. In September 2005, Graves attempted to file an insurance claim on his 1996 BMW reporting the front bumper, lower cowling and undercarriage was damaged after it lunged forward and struck a curb. The claim was denied, however, because Graves’ insurance was not in effect. Graves activated his insurance the next day and attempted to file another claim for the same damage – the claim was denied. But, Graves was not through. In April 2006, he purchased insurance on the same vehicle with a different insurance company. Then in August, he filed a claim for the same damage that had occurred in September of 2005. The insurer paid Graves over $3,800.00 before learning of his fraud. Troopers arrested Graves and booked him into the Caddo Parish Jail on a charge of Insurance Fraud.

    Lastly, Kristin Childers, of Summer Grove, Shreveport, Louisiana, was arrested on June 7, 2007. Troopers believe Childers, a licensed Louisiana agent, created at least 78 fraudulent insurance applications and submitted them to her employer. As a result, she received in excess of $15,800 in advance commissions she was not entitled to. Troopers also learned Childers failed to report a felony theft conviction on a renewal insurance producer application which she submitted to the Louisiana Department of Insurance. Childers was arrested and charged in Caddo Parish with Felony Theft and Filing False Public Records. She was also issued a Cease and Desist Order by the Louisiana Department of Insurance.

    These arrests show the wide variety of cases investigated by LSP’s Insurance Fraud and Auto Theft Unit. The Unit is part of a joint task force comprised of the Louisiana State Police, the Louisiana Department of Insurance and the Louisiana Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney General. The task force is designed to deter, investigate and prosecute insurance fraud related crimes throughout Louisiana. Insurance fraud is a major contributing factor to rising insurance premiums making all Louisiana citizens victims of the often called “victimless” crime.

    June 5, 2007

    On Tuesday, June 5, 2007, the Louisiana State Police Insurance Fraud and Auto Theft Unit arrested two Natchitoches Parish residents on felony insurance fraud warrants. Troopers believe Christopher Bonier, age 31, of Carrolls Camp in Chestnut and Liza Telsee, age 36, of Lebrum Street in Campti, intentionally crashed the tractor portion of a tractor-trailer for the sole purpose of filing fraudulent property damage and bodily injury insurance claims. The investigation revealed Telsee and Bonier staged the crash by disconnecting a flatbed trailer from the tractor, then steering the tractor off the road into a nearby tree. The two claimed the trailer was defective and separated from the tractor while the vehicle was traveling at 55 miles per hour – but the evidence at the scene clearly did not match their statements. Telsee and Bonier were arrested after they voluntarily surrendered to State Police Investigators in Red River Parish, where the staged crash occurred. They were charged with one count each of Insurance Fraud.

    2007 Storm Awareness Fact Sheet
    May 29, 2007
    • 31% of the Louisiana’s households have flood insurance.
       
    • Flood insurance policies have increased 25% in Louisiana in the past year, to 495,200 policies.
       
    • 20 to 25% of all flood claims occur outside of the floodplain, in low to moderate flood risk areas.
       
    • Louisiana’s close proximity to the Mississippi River and Gulf of Mexico, as well as the 50 rivers, streams and bayous in the state, leave many of our 1.6 million households at an increased flood risk.
       
    • In the last 10 years, Louisiana has experienced 11 flood-related, federally declared disasters.
       
    • There is a 26% chance of experiencing a flood during the life of a 30-year mortgage, compared to a 9% chance of fire.
       
    • Losses due to flooding are not covered under typical homeowners and business insurance policies.
       
    • Over the past five hurricane seasons, from 2002-2006, insured flood losses in Louisiana totaled more than $13.4 billion.
       
    • Approximately 96% of flood insurance claims in Louisiana have occurred during hurricane season over the past 10 years.
       
    • Some of the most damaging floods after a hurricane occur hundreds of miles from the coast.
       
    • Homeowners can purchase a flood insurance policy that offers a maximum of $250,000 coverage on the building and $100,000 coverage for contents. However, excess flood insurance coverage can be purchased for properties that need to be insured at a higher value.
       
    • Renters and lessees who meet underwriting criteria are eligible for contents-only coverage.
       
    • There is typically a 30-day waiting period before a flood insurance policy takes effect.
       
    • The Atlantic hurricane season starts June 1 and runs through November 30.
       
    • The Atlantic hurricane season typically peaks between August 1 and late October.
       
    • The 2007 Atlantic hurricane season will be active with 13 to 17 named storms, 7 to 10 of which are expected to become hurricanes, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
       
    • Of the 7 to 10 hurricanes forecast, 3 to 5 will be major ones of Category 3 or higher, with winds over 111 miles per hour, according to the NOAA annual forecast.
       
    • Hurricane Katrina: $16.7 billion in Louisiana insured losses; Over 720,000 claims filed.
       
    • Hurricane Rita: $2.6 billion in Louisiana insured losses; Over 201,000 claims filed.




    Newsletter

    True Blue Report - Volume III, Issue 3 - October 2007

    True Blue Report - Volume III, Issue 2 - July 2007

    True Blue Report - Volume III, Issue 1 - April 2007

    True Blue Report - Volume II, Issue 3 - October 2006

    True Blue Report - Volume II, Issue 2 - July 2006

    True Blue Report - Volume II, Issue 1 - April 2006

    True Blue Report - Volume I, Issue 3 - October 2005

    True Blue Report - Volume I, Issue 2 - July 2005

    True Blue Report - Volume I, Issue 1 - April 2005




    Insurance Fraud Statistics

    "Insurance fraud, whether committed by sophisticated criminals, otherwise honest consumers, or by insurance company employees and owners, is an increasingly expensive burden on the U.S. economy, affecting all citizens. This illegal activity diverts vital resources away from businesses, law enforcement, the civil justice system, regulatory agencies and local emergency services", states the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud.

    Insurance fraud is the second costliest white-collar crime in America, after tax evasion. It is estimated that $80 billion is paid out each year in fraudulent insurance claims. It is estimated by the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud that the average American household pays over $950 a year in additional premiums to cover the cost of insurance fraud. Healthcare Fraud alone costs Americans $54 billion a year according to industry estimates.

    The Insurance Research Council revealed some alarming information obtained from a recent survey regarding types of insurance crime that is considered "acceptable" by an unusually high percentage of the public. These types of insurance fraud include the following followed by the percentage of those surveyed who felt that it was acceptable:
    • Increasing the claim to cover the deductible - 40%
    • Increasing the claim to cover the premiums paid - 36%
    • Including defective or obsolete appliances on a lightning claim - 29%
    • Listing adults as main driver of a car being driven by an under age driver - 20%
    • Omitting accidents/tickets from an insurance application - 14%
    • Continuing medical treatment to increase the value of a claim - 11%
    • Pretending a hit-and-run accident occurred to submit a claim - 7%
    • Abandoning a car and reporting it stolen to the insurance company - 6%
    • Reporting an injury at home as work related in order to collect workers' compensation benefits - 10%
    • Cooperating with lawyers, doctors or chiropractors to file false or exaggerated workers' compensation claims to get money from insurers - 17%
    Insurance fraud is a crime that costs Louisiana citizens alone over 2.3 billion dollars a year, through higher taxes, increased insurance premiums, and higher costs of goods and services.




    Red Flags of Insurance Fraud

    Worker's Compensation Premium Fraud - occurs when an employer provides false information in order to obtain a lower insurance rating.

    Red Flags:
    • The employee's injuries are not consistent with the employee's job classification or the nature of the business.
    • The employee states that his/her employer is other than what is listed on the claim form.
    • The employee disputes information supplied by the employer on the first report of injury.
    • The employee disputes the average weekly wage due additional income (i.e., cash, per diem, and/or 1099 income).
    • There are cross-outs and erasures on the injury forms.
    • The employer refuses to cooperate in the claims investigation; refuses to provide employee with claim form.
    • Employer's witnesses to the accident are generally management personnel.
    • The employer is routinely cited for safety violations.
    • Employer paying medical bills and not reporting injuries.
    Worker's Compensation Fraud - occurs when an employee files an inflated or false injury claim in order to receive benefits or increase benefits.

    Red Flags:
    • Employee is disgruntled, soon-to-retire, or facing imminent firing or layoff.
    • Employee takes more time off than the claimed injury seems to warrant.
    • Employee is new on the job.
    • Employee is experiencing financial difficulties and/or domestic problems prior to submission of claim.
    • Employee is unusually familiar with workers' compensation claim handling procedures and laws.
    • Employee has several other family members also receiving workers' compensation benefits or other "social insurance" benefits, i.e. unemployment.
    • Surveillance or "tip" indicates that the totally disabled worker is currently employed elsewhere.
    • Employee comes to office for delivery of benefit checks, avoids use of US Mail.
    • Employee cancels or fails to keep appointment, or refuses a diagnostic procedure to confirm an injury.
    • Social Security number provided does not belong to employee.
    • Employee refuses or cannot produce solid or correct identification.
    Staged Accident Fraud - occurs when a person intentionally causes or is involved in an accident, or walks in and reports an accident in order to receive compensation for false or intentional damages and injuries.

    Red Flags:
    • Claimant has prior accidents of similar circumstances.
    • Claimant has multiple past claims with same attorney.
    • Claimant is unemployed.
    • Lack of familiar or personal relationships between occupants of claimant vehicle.
    • Inconsistencies in multiple claimants' versions of seating in vehicle, why claimants were in vehicle, and destination of claimants.
    • Claimant demonstrates familiarity with claims process and claim evaluation.
    • Presence of an overly enthusiastic witness at the accident scene.
    • Claimant has recently purchased vehicle, and/or insurance.
    • Victim is usually female or elderly.
    Property Fraud - the falsification or inflation of a claim for the loss of personal property in order to obtain a larger settlement.

    Red Flags:
    • Insured is overly pushy for a quick settlement.
    • Insured handles all business in person, thus avoiding the use of the mail.
    • Losses are incompatible with insured's resident, occupation and/or income.
    • Losses include a large amount of cash.
    • Insured is willing to accept an inordinately small settlement rather than document all claims losses.
    • Buildings and/or contents were up for sale at the time of the loss.
    • Suspiciously coincidental absence of family pet at the time of fire.
    • Building and/or business was recently purchased.
    • Building is in deteriorating condition and/or lacks proper maintenance.
    • Fire scene investigation reveals absence of items of sentimental value; e.g. family Bible, family photos, trophies.
    • No police report or an over-the-counter report in situations where police would normally investigate.
    • Insured's loss inventory differs significantly from police department's crime report.
    Disaster Fraud - occurs in the aftermath of a disaster when the insured claims false or inflated claims on intentionally caused or pre-existing damage.

    Red Flags:
    • Insured declares extensive losses without physical evidence, photographs or documented receipts.
    • Items claimed to not match claimant's lifestyle, decor, house, occupation or income.
    • Lack of carpet indentation from alleged large furniture or appliances.
    • Insured is overly pushy for quick settlement.
    • Investigation reveals absence of family photographs, heirlooms or items of sentimental value.
    • Affected area was not evacuated.
    • No other homes were damaged or destroyed in the affected area.
    • Insured claims items were new.
    • Insured can't properly describe items as to function or features.
    • Insured property was not located in major damaged area.
    • Property was in poor condition prior to loss.
    • Insured cannot produce damaged item(s) for viewing.
    • Insured claims unrepaired damage from a previous disaster.
    Securities / Promissory Notes Fraud - the marketing and selling of investment opportunities that do not qualify with the regulations set forth by or have not been registered with the Office of Financial Institutions.

    Red Flags:
    • Unbelievable interest rate offered on investment. If it seems "to good to be true". . . it probably is.
    • An agent or other representative urges you to pay with cash.
    • A salesperson urges you to cash in your certificates of deposit (despite the interest penalty) and put the money into investments, annuities, or life insurance policies.
    Vehicle Theft Fraud - occurs when the owner of a vehicle disposes of or fraudulently reports their vehicle stolen in an attempt secure a settlement.

    Red Flags:
    • Insured has lived at current address less than six months, or been with current employer less than six months.
    • Insured does not have a telephone or is difficult to contact.
    • Insured is unemployed.
    • Insured claims expensive contents in vehicle at the time of theft.
    • Insured is behind in loan payments on vehicle and/or other financial obligations.
    • Insured has a previous history of vehicle theft claims.
    • Vehicle was recently purchased.
    • Vehicle has a history of mechanical problems or is a "gas guzzler".
    • Vehicle has incorrect VIN, or VIN is different than VIN appearing on the title.
    • Vehicle is recovered with seized engine or blown transmission.
    • Vehicle is recovered stripped, burned, or has severe collision damage within a short duration of the time after loss allegedly occurred.
    • Loss occurs within one month of issue or expiration of the policy.
    • Coverage was obtained via walk-in business to agent.
    • Coverage is for minimum liability with full comprehensive coverage on late model and/or expensive vehicle.
    • Police report has not been made by insured or has been delayed.
    • License plate does not match vehicle and/or is not registered to insured.
    • Salvage yard or repair garage takes unusual interest in claim.



    Other Links

  • Coalition Against Insurance Fraud
     
  • National Association of Insurance Commissioners
     
  • LA Department of Insurance
     
  • LA Department of Justice
     
  • National Insurance Crime Bureau
     
  • National White Collar Crime Center